- 0
- 1,488 word
Is Jaggery Really Healthier Than Sugar? What Nutritionists Want You To Know This Monsoon
Is jaggery healthier than sugar? Nutritionists explain the real difference between jaggery, desi khand and refined sugar, and what to know this monsoon.
Summarized by AI.
Got Question about the News?
The monsoon often changes the way we eat. Warm drinks replace cold beverages, cravings for traditional comfort foods return, and ingredients that have been part of Indian kitchens for generations once again find their way into our meals.
Among them are jaggery and desi khand, both of which are frequently promoted as healthier alternatives to refined white sugar.
Recommended Stories
But is that really the case?
While jaggery and desi khand may be less refined than table sugar and can contain small amounts of naturally occurring minerals, nutritionists caution against treating them as health foods. All three are still sources of sugar, and the quantity consumed matters more than whether the sweetener is marketed as natural or traditional.
So, this monsoon, before replacing your sugar jar with jaggery or desi khand, here’s what you actually need to know.
Is Jaggery Healthier Than Sugar?
Jaggery is often considered a healthier alternative to refined sugar because it undergoes less processing and retains some of the components of sugarcane juice, including molasses.
It can contain small amounts of minerals such as iron, potassium and calcium, which are largely absent from highly refined white sugar.
However, that doesn’t automatically make jaggery a healthy food.
Arooshi Aggarwal, Nutritionist, feels jaggery is still essentially a source of simple sugar. While it may provide small amounts of minerals, the nutritional difference does not make it a free pass to consume larger quantities.
“Gur and desi khand are traditional foods, but they should not be considered ‘monsoon remedy’ foods,” says Aggarwal. “They can be used in small quantities to sweeten foods and drinks, but claims that they specifically prevent coughs, colds or infections, or significantly improve immunity, are not well established.”
In other words, switching from white sugar to jaggery may give you a slightly different nutritional profile, but it does not transform a sugary food into a health food.
What About Desi Khand?
Desi khand is another traditional sweetener that is often positioned as a more natural alternative to refined sugar.
Like jaggery, it is less refined and may retain small amounts of minerals from molasses. It also has a relatively mild flavour, which makes it easy to use in everyday preparations such as tea, kheer and homemade snacks.
But nutritionally, the difference between desi khand and refined sugar should not be exaggerated.
Aggarwal explains that desi khand is still a form of sugar and that its overall health impact is relatively modest compared with refined sugar when consumed in similar quantities.
So while you may prefer its taste or traditional preparation, desi khand should not be treated as a significantly healthier substitute for sugar.
Why Do Jaggery And Khand Feature So Much In Monsoon Eating?
This is where traditional food wisdom comes into the picture.
Jaggery has traditionally been associated with monsoon eating because of its warming nature.
Ayurveda has long classified jaggery as ‘ushna’, or warming in nature, which makes it particularly suited to the damp, cooler days of monsoon. It is traditionally consumed after meals or added to preparations such as ginger and tulsi kadha, particularly when digestion and appetite feel sluggish.
This traditional association explains why jaggery frequently appears in warm beverages and seasonal preparations during the rainy months.
It can add a rich, earthy sweetness to ginger drinks, kadhas and traditional desserts, making it as much a culinary ingredient as a part of seasonal food culture.
However, traditional use and modern nutritional evidence aren’t necessarily the same thing.
The fact that an ingredient has been consumed traditionally during a particular season does not mean it has been scientifically proven to prevent seasonal illnesses.
Does Jaggery Boost Immunity During The Monsoon?
This is one of the claims that deserves the most scrutiny. Jaggery is frequently described as an immunity-boosting food, particularly during the monsoon when colds, coughs and other infections are common.
But there isn’t strong evidence to suggest that simply eating jaggery prevents infections or significantly strengthens immunity.
As Aggarwal points out, claims that jaggery or desi khand specifically prevent coughs, colds or infections are not well established.
That doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy jaggery in your food. It simply means it is better to think of it as a sweetener, rather than a seasonal medicine.
Is Desi Khand A Better Choice?
If you’re choosing between refined sugar, jaggery and desi khand, the answer depends partly on what you mean by “better”.
From a culinary perspective, you may prefer one for its flavour, texture or traditional use.
From a nutritional perspective, however, the difference is less dramatic than wellness marketing sometimes suggests.
Jaggery and desi khand may retain small quantities of minerals because they are less refined, but they are still concentrated sources of sugar.
So if you’re already consuming a lot of added sugar, simply swapping white sugar for jaggery or desi khand without reducing the quantity may not make a meaningful difference.
How Much Is Too Much?
This is where portion size matters. Natural, traditional or less-refined sweeteners are still calorie-containing foods. This is particularly important for people who are managing their weight, diabetes or insulin resistance.
Aggarwal recommends moderation rather than treating jaggery or desi khand as unlimited alternatives to refined sugar.
For most healthy adults, a small quantity used occasionally can fit into an otherwise balanced diet, while total added sugar intake should remain within recommended limits.
The bigger picture matters more than which sweetener you choose.
A cup of tea with a teaspoon of jaggery is still a sweetened drink. A dessert made with desi khand is still a dessert. Changing the sweetener doesn’t erase the sugar.
What Should You Eat For Better Monsoon Wellness?
If your goal is to stay healthy through the rainy season, nutritionists recommend looking beyond one ingredient.
A balanced monsoon diet should prioritise freshly prepared meals, adequate protein, seasonal fruits and vegetables, safe drinking water and good food hygiene.
Food safety is particularly important during the monsoon because changes in temperature and humidity can affect food storage and increase the risk of contamination.
So instead of asking whether jaggery is a “monsoon superfood”, a better approach is to look at your overall eating pattern.
Use jaggery or desi khand if you enjoy them, but use them as sweeteners rather than remedies.
The Bottom Line: Jaggery Isn’t A Magic Healthier Sugar
So, is jaggery healthier than sugar? Not in the way the popular health narrative often suggests. Jaggery is less refined and may contain small amounts of minerals that refined sugar does not. Desi khand similarly retains some characteristics of less-refined sugar. But both remain sources of sugar, and the nutritional differences should not be overstated.
That means you don’t necessarily need to eliminate jaggery or desi khand from your kitchen this monsoon. But you also don’t need to start consuming them because you believe they will prevent infections, detox the body or dramatically improve immunity.
The more useful takeaway is simple: choose the sweetener you enjoy, watch the quantity and focus more on the overall quality of your diet.
Traditional ingredients can absolutely have a place at the table. They just don’t need to be marketed as miracle foods to earn it.
Quick Answers
Ask News18Stevia and monk fruit are plant-based sweeteners that offer sweetness with minimal calories and little impact on blood glucose levels. Other natural alternatives to refined sugar include honey, coconut sugar, date sugar, and maple syrup.
Ask News18About the Author
Original source: https://www.news18.com/lifestyle/food/
Author
admin@myncblogs.com